Boiling vs steaming, which is better?

Boiling or steaming? This is the question.

Cooking with water is a great technique, no question about it. Cooks have to choose between two methods, though: steaming and boiling.

Steaming versus boiling

Water is used in several cooking methods, such as steaming and boiling. Many vegetables are cooked with water because it is a light, healthy way to cook them. But what can you boil or steam? You are certainly not limited to just vegetables.

When cooking vegetables, it is important to consider the method used, as it can significantly impact the nutrient retention, color, texture, and taste of the vegetables. No oils or fats are incorporated into those vegetables when steamed and they retain more nutrients. 

Steam knocks it out the park

Steaming means boiling water so that it turns into steam, and the steam is what cooks the food. Steaming vegetables helps to retain more nutrients, resulting in brighter colors, a crisper texture, and a better taste. For those watching calories and fat, steaming is a very effective way to cook, since you don't need to add anything. Steaming keeps food in its original form. Something important to remember when steaming is that you are not putting the food directly in water. The food sits above the water, and the steam rises up to cook it.

Steaming has its ups and downs, though. On the plus side, it is gentle: because the food never sits in water, it keeps its shape, nutrients and texture, and it is a little more forgiving than boiling. Food can still overcook if you leave it too long, so check it often.

For even cooking, keep the water at a steady boil so there is a constant supply of steam, and don't let the pot boil dry.

Steaming is usually only used to cook vegetables, but some meats can be steamed. Beef, pork and even chicken can be cooked this way, if cut thinly. It gives meat a different taste that some people may not like, although many prefer the texture and flavor of steamed food to boiled food. Seafood is a very common food to be steamed. Fish does very well and even shrimp taste wonderful.

Boiling isn't far behind

Boiling is also a very effective way of cooking. Though it is similar to steaming, there are differences. Unlike steaming, boiling requires the food to actually sit in the water, so boiling vegetables can lead to nutrient loss, dull flavor, and a watery texture. You can boil vegetables, meats and seafood; basically all the things you can steam, but the taste and health values will change. Although boiling can cause significant nutrient loss, it is one of the best methods for reducing compounds such as oxalates, found in spinach and some other vegetables.

Boiling or cooking food directly in the water gives the nutrients a chance to move from the food to the water. It also doesn't spice up the food nor does it give it that appetizing color that foods get from grilling or baking. Boiled foods can lose flavor because some of it goes into the water, which is why boiling liquid is often used for soups and stocks.

Here is just a brief list of the positives of boiling:

  • Doesn't require any added fats
  • It's easy, it doesn't require you to be hovering over your stove for hours
  • It takes those tough pieces of meat and makes them able to eat
  • It is perfect for large scale cooking

These are just a few of the reasons boiling is great. Grab a steamer or fill a pot with water and see for yourself just how great they both can be.

Boiling and Steaming

Flavorful meat: Prepare the meat before steaming to avoid a dry and flavorless outcome. Marinate meat in olive oil with spices or aromatic herbs – rosemary, sage, tarragon- or use a spice mix or rub before cooking.

Food in its best looks: You don't need to turn food over when you steam so there is no risk of piercing, breaking or spoiling it and it will look its best on the platter. As a bonus, steaming preserves color very well.

Fresh, fresh food: It's essential that any food to be steamed is fresh. Steaming does not mix or cover flavors as poaching and stewing do. Producing a delicious steamed dish happens as the natural outcome of using top quality, fresh ingredients.

Heat destroys vitamins: Whichever cooking method you use, some of the A, B and C vitamins are lost, especially vitamin C.

Juicy steamed fish: Steaming is a very simple way to prepare delicious fish dishes. Steamed fish comes out excellent and only needs a sauce to add flavor. Cook it until it flakes easily (145°F). Only be aware that it is best to steam the whole fish – trout, red mullet - or large pieces – tuna, salmon, cod - as small pieces easily come out dry.

Regular vegetables: To prepare steamed vegetables, choose those of a similar shape and weight or cut them in pieces of the same size. This way, they will all cook to the same point, at the same time.

Rice, couscous or quinoa to the steam: When cooking food that comes in tiny bits -such as rice, couscous or quinoa- cover the bottom grid with a cheesecloth, or place the food in a cheesecloth. This not only will prevent the bits from going through the grid, it will make removing the food much easier.

Steam several dishes at once: Save yourself some time in the kitchen and prepare several recipes - or one main course and side dishes - in one go. Place every food in a basket at a different level and everything will cook with the same steam. Put first - closer to the boiling water - the food that needs cooking for longer, and position the other basket in reverse order – more cooking time to less - and everything will be ready at the same time.

Steam to get lean: Make rolls with white fish fillets and steam them like that. Serve them with a dash of hollandaise or a similar sauce. Scrumptious and a blessing for waistlines as the fish fillets are cooked without fat.

Vegetables to the steam: All vegetables are ideal for steaming, except those with large green leaves – spinach, chard, beet greens - because they lose color, flavor and texture.