Old World versus New World wines: notes from a March 2010 wine tasting.
France, Italy, Spain and most other European wine-producing countries make up the Old World. Australia, New Zealand and the Americas are part of the New World, which embraced many new winemaking techniques. South Africa, with centuries of winemaking history, is usually counted as New World but often has a foot in both camps. These notes come from a wine tasting held in March 2010.
Tesco Finest Prosecco di Valdobbiadene. Non-vintage, Veneto, Italy, alcohol 11.5%
Prosecco is probably the best known of the Italian sparkling wines and is increasingly popular in the UK. It is made by the Charmat, or closed tank, method, which usually results in a softer, fruitier wine than Champagne and other wines produced by the traditional method. The tasting wine is made from the Glera grape, formerly also called Prosecco, in the Veneto. It is produced for one of the leading UK supermarkets by one of the best Prosecco producers, Bisol, which owns its own vineyards and production facilities. This is a creamy, smooth sparkler with notes of peach and pear. Good as a light aperitif and with smoked salmon.
Villa Maria Sauvignon Blanc 2009. Marlborough, New Zealand, alcohol 13%
The launch of Cloudy Bay Sauvignon Blanc in the mid-1980s changed the perception of Sauvignon Blanc in many countries and put New Zealand on the map as a winemaking country. Previously, Sauvignon Blanc came mainly from the Loire, such as Sauvignon de Touraine, and varied with the ripeness of each vintage in this northerly wine area. Almost overnight, New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc became associated with powerful fruit flavors and very characteristic gooseberry notes. Over the years, those notes have been toned down a little, and today much New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc also shows softer, sometimes tropical fruit notes. The tasting wine is from Marlborough, on the South Island, which produces around three-quarters of all New Zealand wine. New Zealand's cool climate suits Sauvignon Blanc, and there are many producers, Oyster Bay among the best known. Chile produces increasing quantities of worthwhile, good-value Sauvignon Blanc, often with more pronounced tropical fruit notes. For a more restrained, mineral Sauvignon Blanc, try the Upper Loire: Sancerre and Pouilly-Fumé can be delightful but are often expensive. La Grille Sauvignon Blanc, made by a leading Sancerre producer from grapes grown outside the appellation, is a good example of an Old World, mineral-driven Sauvignon Blanc. Sauvignon Blanc goes well with shellfish and other simple seafood.
Barón de Barbón White Rioja 2008. Rioja Alavesa, Spain, alcohol 13%
Rioja is the best-known Spanish wine area, and only around 10% of its wine is white. Like many other parts of Spain, Rioja has changed enormously in recent years. Heavily oaked, sometimes musty wines may still exist, but younger, fruit-driven wines made with greater use of stainless steel are now the norm. The move to stainless steel has created something of a revival for Spanish white wines, including in Rueda, where the traditional Verdejo grape now has a new life producing crisp, refreshing wines, often blended with Sauvignon Blanc. The tasting wine is made from the Viura grape, which elsewhere in Spain is often called Macabeo and is a major element of Cava. Significantly, the wine is unoaked, an example of the new breed of Spanish whites. It is crisp and citrusy with some underlying tropical notes. A refreshing wine that goes with seafood, white meats and other lighter dishes.
Olivier Merlin La Roche Vineuse Vieilles Vignes 2005. Mâcon, France, alcohol 13.5%
A quality white Burgundy can be an ethereal experience, but sadly often an expensive one. Outside the expensive Côte de Beaune villages such as Meursault, wines can be less expensive but no less satisfying. The Mâconnais remains a largely underrated area, although quality varies considerably. The tasting wine is produced by Olivier Merlin, a highly regarded perfectionist. Like many Burgundian producers, he makes an extensive range of small-volume wines reflecting different terroirs. This one is from the small area of La Roche-Vineuse and is made from vines about 45 years old. It is an elegant wine that goes well with smoked salmon and suits special occasions.
Colomé Torrontés 2007. Calchaquí Valley, Salta, Argentina, alcohol 13.5%
Argentina produces a wide range of wines, in larger volumes than Chile. As a major beef-producing and beef-eating country, it is perhaps not surprising that its best-known wines are red. However, the country also produces intensely flavored white wines, thanks in part to the altitude of its Andean vineyards, among the highest in the world, particularly in the northern province of Salta. Vines grown at altitude benefit from warm days and cool nights, and the higher levels of ultraviolet light help produce greater flavor intensity. The dry air also keeps many vine pests and diseases at bay, contributing to healthy and often long-lived vines. The tasting wine is made from Torrontés, a grape now virtually unique to Argentina, from vines between 50 and 120 years old growing at 6,500 to 7,500 feet. Old vines produce fewer grapes, but with greater intensity of flavor. At the time of the tasting, this was only the estate's second vintage of Torrontés, and it had already won a Decanter trophy. Colomé is a biodynamic estate. Expect a distinctive, highly aromatic wine with rich tropical fruit and floral notes balanced by good acidity. It would go well with richer foods, including Thai and Chinese dishes. In the Old World, Alsace produces the most aromatic wines, including Muscat and Gewürztraminer.
Bodegas Esmeralda Estiba I Bonarda 2008. Mendoza, Argentina, alcohol 13.5%
The popularity of Malbec and other international red grapes can obscure the fact that for many years Bonarda was Argentina's most planted red grape. It remains popular and widely available in Argentina but is harder to find in stores abroad. Despite its Italian name, Argentine Bonarda has been identified as Douce Noir, also known as Charbono, a grape from the Savoie region of France. It has a long ripening season and flourishes in the conditions around Mendoza. Often lighter than Malbec, it can sometimes be mistaken for lighter wines such as Beaujolais or Pinot Noir. The tasting wine is 100% Bonarda, produced by the Catena family company, which also makes the good-value Argento range. It has notes of fresh strawberries, light floral notes and a soft, rounded finish.
La Différence Carignan, Vin de Pays des Côtes Catalanes. Roussillon, France, 2008, alcohol 13.5%
The combination of an unfashionable grape and a little-known area can be a recipe for distinctiveness and value. When young, Carignan vines produce somewhat characterless wine, and since the 1960s very little Carignan has been planted, so many Carignan vines are now very old. Old-vine Carignan produces a very different wine, with rich and concentrated flavors. Parts of the Languedoc, particularly Minervois, now have old-vine Carignan capable of producing characterful wine. The tasting wine is from a little-known Vin de Pays area near Perpignan and is 100% Carignan from vines averaging 60 years old. This is a complex wine with layers of prune, chocolate and herbs. It would go well with spicy meats, barbecues and mature cheeses such as cheddar; a wine that has won many gold medals and is particularly good value.
Ravenswood Lodi Old Vine Zinfandel 2006. California, alcohol 14.5%
Zinfandel is the same grape as Primitivo, from southeast Italy, and both trace back to an old Croatian variety. In the U.S., Zinfandel's reputation is mixed. Its association with cheap and cheerful wines stretching back to Gold Rush days means it is sometimes seen as less sophisticated than grapes such as Pinot Noir and Cabernet Sauvignon. However, Zinfandel can make high-quality wines, some of them highly sought after and expensive. The tasting wine is made by Ravenswood, a Sonoma-based Zinfandel specialist, from old vines averaging 85 years in the Lodi area of California. It is 84% Zinfandel, 12% Petite Sirah and 4% other grapes. Expect lots of deep, dark fruit notes and hints of spice; a wine for heartier red meat dishes and mature cheese. Ravenswood's most popular Zinfandel is the more widely available Vintners Blend, a little cheaper and good, but perhaps not as distinctive as this one.
MontGras Reserva Carmenère 2008. Colchagua Valley, Chile, alcohol 14.5%
Carmenère vines were originally brought to Chile from Bordeaux in the 19th century. Today, very little Carmenère is grown in Bordeaux. Carmenère has some similarity with Merlot, and until 1994 the Carmenère vines in Chile were thought to be Merlot, until DNA testing revealed the difference. Carmenère ripens later than Merlot, which gives it more concentrated flavors; its profile is somewhere between Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon. Chile now correctly markets much of its former "Merlot" as Carmenère. The tasting wine is made by MontGras, a winery founded in the early 1990s, from grapes grown on a single estate. It is 90% Carmenère and 10% Cabernet Sauvignon. It has an intense red color (the name Carmenère is said to come from carmine, crimson), with dark fruit flavors and perhaps some chocolate and herb or spice notes. Its soft tannins make it easy drinking. This wine goes well with a wide range of meat dishes, particularly lamb with plenty of herbs.
Churchill Estates Douro. Douro Valley, Portugal, alcohol 14%
Port, particularly vintage port, is less popular these days, so many port houses now also produce table wines from the traditional port grapes, and some producers make only table wine. The tasting wine is from a relatively young port house that produces both port and table wines. It is made from 40% Touriga Nacional, 30% Touriga Franca and 30% Tinta Roriz. Expect cherry and strawberry notes and a smooth, velvety finish. This wine would go well with mature cheese.
Willunga 100 Grenache 2006. McLaren Vale, Australia, alcohol 14.5%
Grenache is one of the world's most planted grapes but is usually part of a blend, notably in the southern Rhône; wines made mostly from Grenache are less common. The grape's characteristics include high sugar and alcohol potential and strong fruit flavors. The tasting wine is 95% Grenache and 5% Shiraz. The name comes from the Hundred of Willunga, an old land division in McLaren Vale, and many of the vines are old. The grapes for this wine are specially selected. This is an intense wine that seems underpriced. It goes well with hearty winter foods.
Colomé Estate Malbec 2005. Calchaquí Valley, Argentina, alcohol 14.5%
The Colomé Estate is in the remote Calchaquí Valley, several hours' drive from the city of Salta. Founded in 1831, it is one of the oldest wineries in Argentina, at around 7,500 feet above sea level, with vineyards planted even higher, close to 10,000 feet. Some of the vines are over 150 years old. At these heights the air is dry, with little mildew and few insects to harm the vines. The estate is biodynamic. The altitude gives intensity to the grapes, helped further by slow, cool fermentation. Colomé produces a Torrontés and several red wines: Amalaya, a lighter red from younger vines; this Estate wine; and a Reserva made in very small quantities from the oldest, lowest-yielding vines, and only in the best years. The tasting wine is 85% Malbec, 10% Cabernet Sauvignon and 5% Tannat. Some of the grapes come from 150-year-old vines, and the rest from vines averaging 60 years. This is a complex wine with great depth and many flavor notes. A wine to savor slowly! The estate also has a small hotel.
Jackson-Triggs Proprietors' Reserve Vidal Icewine 2007. Niagara Peninsula, Canada, alcohol 10.5%
Icewine is made in small quantities in parts of the world with severe winters, such as Germany, Austria and Canada. Its production depends on the weather at harvest time. The grapes are left on the vine into winter and picked only when they are frozen solid, at temperatures of about 17°F (-8°C) or colder. Inevitably, there is considerable loss, with many grapes eaten by birds, falling off or rotting. The late harvest, however, concentrates the sugars and flavors in the grapes. They have to be picked by hand, often at night, and rushed to the winery, where they are pressed while still frozen, so the ice stays behind and only a small amount of very concentrated juice flows out. The juice is then fermented, usually in stainless steel to retain the flavors. The tasting wine is made from the Vidal grape in the Niagara Peninsula of Ontario. Its flavors include mango, papaya and apricot. The wine has won many international awards, and it is extraordinary value considering the costs, risks and difficulties of production. It goes well with fresh tropical fruit, liver pâté and foie gras.
These tasting notes were written in March 2010. Vintages, blends and availability will have changed since then.
Last reviewed November 2026.