Even with modern winemaking and shipping, a small share of wines reach the table spoiled. Here's how to spot them.
Even with modern winemaking, storage and shipping, a small percentage of wines reach the table spoiled to some degree. Here are some tips on how to spot them.
Corked wine
It all begins with a cork... Even in this age of screw caps and synthetic stoppers, many bottles are still sealed with an old-fashioned cork. Made from the bark of the cork oak, which grows around the western Mediterranean, corks have many desirable and hard-to-duplicate qualities: they are light, flexible, elastic, nearly airtight and attractive.
But cork, as a natural product, can be attacked by microorganisms. Certain molds, reacting with chlorine compounds, can produce a chemical called TCA (2,4,6-trichloroanisole, for those interested) in the cork, or even in the winery itself.
TCA gives wine unpleasant odors and tastes, like wet cardboard, a damp basement, moldy newspaper or wet dog. Even when the smell is faint, the wine tastes flat and dull, and lacks fruit. A corked wine is not harmful to drink, just unpleasant.
Cooked wine
Moving wine from the winery to the home or restaurant table involves trips of anywhere from a few miles to thousands. Given that, it's remarkable that so few wines are damaged by heat along the way.
High temperatures make wine expand slightly, which increases the pressure inside a corked bottle and can push the cork up. When the wine cools down again, air can seep in.
If the temperature gets high enough, the wine can literally be cooked, and the taste will show it: the fruit will taste more like stewed prunes or jam than fresh berries. Look for corks pushed up above the lip of the bottle, sticky wine stains around the capsule, or a wine level well below the neck.
Oxidation
Poor storage, such as heat, temperature swings or very dry conditions, can make corks shrink or crack, letting too much air into the bottle and causing oxidation. Oxidation is what it sounds like: oxygen reacting with many of the wine's components and changing them.
A tiny amount of air over many years is part of how wine ages. But too much air spoils a wine long before it could ever turn to vinegar. A white wine that has turned brownish, or any wine that tastes flat and fruitless and smells nutty, like sherry or Madeira, wines that are deliberately oxidized, has almost certainly been exposed to too much air.
Sulfur and sediment
Sulfur dioxide is a common preservative in winemaking that helps protect and stabilize wine. But in excess it gives an unpleasant, sharp smell of burnt matches, and a related fault, hydrogen sulfide, smells of rotten eggs. Both are easy to spot.
Some sediment in wine is normal and acceptable. Ports and older red wines often throw a deposit, and they are fine when carefully poured or decanted. Tartrate crystals, sometimes called wine diamonds, can also form naturally in white wines when they are chilled. They do no harm, but you'll want to leave them in the bottle.
Refermentation
In rare cases, a little yeast and sugar can remain in a wine, and fermentation can start again in the bottle. Champagne, of course, is deliberately fermented a second time in the bottle. But in a still wine, an unexpected prickle of bubbles is a fault, and easy to spot. Some light wines, such as Vinho Verde, are meant to have a slight spritz, though.
Winemaking, bottling, shipping and storage keep improving, and the odds of meeting one of these faults are small. If a wine is sound but you don't like it, chances are it simply isn't for you. If you suspect a fault, especially in a restaurant, don't hesitate to say so: a corked or cooked bottle should be replaced.
Modern technology has greatly reduced these problems. Temperature-controlled storage and refrigerated transport are among the best things that ever happened to wine.